← Business ethics
✕ Don’t

Don’t overcharge

The same price for the same service; discounts only by the rules.

When you sell something to your neighbor or buy from them, do not wrong one another.

Bible, Leviticus 25:14 · Maimonides

The essence

A price should be fair compared to the market and the same for people in the same circumstances. The rule works both ways — for the seller and for the buyer, whether on purpose or by mistake. Making a profit is not forbidden: what is forbidden is profiting from the fact that a person doesn’t know the real price. An open, explained price — even a high one — is honest.

If you follow itThe client doesn’t haggle or check prices elsewhere — they trust the price list. Fewer arguments at the counter and fewer refunds, and raising prices is easier when the price is honest and explained.
If you break itAccording to the source, the excess must be returned, and if the difference is large, the deal can be cancelled. In business, a client who finds out someone else paid less doesn’t come back — and tells their friends about it.
How this shows up in pay

Discounts only by written rules: nobody gets a bonus for a discount “out of their own pocket”, and discounts outside the rules are a guardrail on the front desk bonus.

Pay breakdown: Administrator →

Stories by role

Choose a role. Three stories of how the principle is kept, and three of how it is broken.

Responsible not for revenue at any cost, but for the system: clients come back, strong people stay, and the money is counted honestly.

✓ How it’s kept

Discount rules on one page

The owner of a three-chair salon noticed that every administrator was giving discounts “by feel”: ten percent to one client, nothing to another. She sat down and wrote one page: who gets a discount, how much and for what. The sheet went up next to the till and into the team chat. Within a month there were noticeably fewer arguments at the counter, and regulars stopped asking “why did my friend pay less?”.

✓ How it’s kept

A new price doesn’t apply to what’s already bought

A chain of skincare studios raised prices because products had become more expensive. The owner decided that everyone who had already bought a course would finish it at the old price, and clients would be told about the new price a month ahead, with the reason explained. Several clients wrote separately to say thank you. There were almost no complaints about the increase — because nobody was caught off guard.

✓ How it’s kept

The price gap that turned up on its own

Once a quarter, the owner of a dental clinic looks at how much different patients paid for the same service. One day he noticed that a professional cleaning with one dentist was consistently more expensive than with the others, though the price list showed no difference. It turned out the dentist was adding “complexity” at his own discretion. They introduced an open “complex case” category with a description — and the price stopped depending on anyone’s mood.

✕ How it’s broken

A target you can only hit by squeezing

The owner of a chain of nail studios gave the front desk an average-bill target and didn’t explain how to reach it. The administrators started “forgetting” regulars’ discounts and adding small paid extras without asking. The target was hit in two months. Six months later, some of the regulars had quietly moved to the studio across the street.

✕ How it’s broken

More expensive for those who’ve already started

The owner of a laser hair removal studio decided to raise the price of the last sessions for clients who were already halfway through their course: “They won’t quit in the middle anyway.” Clients found out at the counter. Most paid the difference, because it felt wasteful to drop the course. But not one of them bought the next course, and two wrote about it in reviews.

✕ How it’s broken

A “friends price” with no rule

For years the salon owner gave friends and acquaintances a “friends price” — well below the price list, with no rule at all. The stylists saw this and started doing the same for their own friends. A year later it turned out that full price was mostly paid by new clients who didn’t know anyone there. One of them overheard a conversation at the front desk — and never came back.

Role guide: Owner / manager →

Nuances: what it says and what it means today

What it says
The prohibition is the same for the seller and the buyer. An overpayment, deliberate or not, is returned.
What it means in a salon or clinic
A mistake in the price list or on the receipt that hurts the client is not “their problem”: the difference is refunded, even if it’s noticed later. And the other way round — a salon or clinic isn’t obliged to work at a loss either.
What it says
The limit is one sixth of the market price: people usually forgive a smaller difference; at exactly one sixth the deal stands but the difference is returned; above that the deal can be cancelled.
What it means in a salon or clinic
A practical benchmark: the price of the same service for different clients shouldn’t swing by more than roughly a sixth without a clear reason — a package, a promotion by the rules, a different level of stylist or doctor.
What it says
A claim can be made within the time it takes the buyer to show the item to an expert or a relative. Whoever waits longer can no longer cancel the deal.
What it means in a salon or clinic
The client has the right to compare and to have doubts. Don’t push “today only” — give them time to think over an expensive course, a membership or a treatment plan.
What it says
For goods that only an expert can value (books, precious stones), the period is longer — until the buyer finds an expert.
What it means in a salon or clinic
Beauty and medical services are exactly like that: a client can’t judge for themselves what a product, a dye, a material or a machine session is worth. So the responsibility for an honest price here is higher, not lower.
What it says
The prohibition applies even to a merchant who knows prices well himself.
What it means in a salon or clinic
An experienced client, a colleague from another salon, a supplier — the same honest price. “She knows what it costs anyway” justifies neither overcharging nor tricks.
What it says
Whoever openly says “I bought it for this much and I’m making this much” does not break the rule. Expenses (porters, drivers, lodging) can be included in the price, but not one’s own pay for the work: one’s earnings must be named openly as profit, with the amount stated.
What it means in a salon or clinic
Transparency matters more than being cheap. “The price includes the product, the doctor’s work and a follow-up check” or “color, treatment and styling” is honest even for a high price.
What it says
The court limits profit to one sixth only on life’s necessities (wine, oil, flour). On perfumes and the like, the seller charges whatever he wants.
What it means in a salon or clinic
Treatment and diagnostics are closer to “necessities” — a moderate markup fits here. Aesthetics, care and design are closer to “perfumes” — the market is freer, but the transparency rule always applies.

Grey areas: difficult cases

Is it fair for the same service to cost more with a senior stylist or a lead doctor?

Yes, if it’s an open category in the price list and the client knows the difference before booking. It’s unfair when the price depends on who comes in, not on who does the work.

Isn’t a discount on morning or free slots a breach of the same-price rule?

No, if the rule is open and the same for everyone who takes such a slot. Maimonides explicitly allows selling cheaper to attract buyers.

Our price for aesthetics or complex design is much higher than next door. Is that overcharging?

Not necessarily. For “luxuries” the seller may charge whatever he wants, as long as he doesn’t hide what the price is made of. The breach is when the client thinks they’re paying the ordinary market price.

A client says: “Price doesn’t matter, do the best.” Can we charge more?

You can offer a more expensive option if it really is better — but at the normal price list. A “price doesn’t matter” when the person doesn’t know the amount doesn’t lift the rule.

We made a mistake on the receipt and the client didn’t notice. What should we do?

If it went against the client, refund the difference, even if you noticed later: an accidental overpayment is returned just like a deliberate one. If it went against you, you can openly explain and correct it, but don’t quietly “win it back” at the next visit.

How to measure it

A price is honest when it’s the same for people in the same circumstances and discounts follow the rules. So it’s worth seeing discounts separately from upsells, and the price spread of a single service across clients.

Discounts separately from upsells — for each administratoralready counts
New clients returning after their first visitalready counts
Client rating of the visitalready counts
Price spread of a single service across clientscoming
Discounts outside the rulescoming
Result of every promotioncoming

Three questions for a team meeting

  1. Can we explain to a client every amount on the bill for our most expensive service?
  2. Where does our price depend on the person rather than the service?
  3. Which of our promotions in the past six months wouldn’t pass the test “a discount off the price that was actually charged before the promotion”?

Who else works this way

These are basic universal principles, tested by companies in different countries regardless of faith and culture, and some of them are written into laws and professional standards.

Costco The founders’ rule: a markup of no more than ~14% on branded goods and ~15% on the store brand — even when they could charge more. Source: commoncog.com
Cost Plus Drugs Since 2022 this pharmacy has sold medicines using the formula “cost + 15% + a fixed pharmacy fee” (currently $5) — everyone can see the markup. Source: en.wikipedia.org
Saturn (GM) From 1990 — the first “one price” car dealership network: the sticker price is final, no haggling, the same for everyone. Source: www.wardsauto.com

We first test these approaches in practice with the salons we work with. We don’t name them or share their numbers — it is their data, and we protect their confidentiality. That is why we cite open sources: you can open and check each one yourself.

Applying these principles to salons and clinics is our interpretation: these are principles of ethics, not legal or medical advice. The stories are fictional; any resemblance is coincidental. Source: Bible · Maimonides