← Business ethics
✕ Don’t

Don’t give false advice

Recommend what the client needs, not what the sales plan needs.

Do not curse the deaf, and do not put a stumbling block before the blind. The verse ends with an appeal to one’s own conscience: only the adviser knows their true intent.

Bible, Leviticus 19:14 · Maimonides

The essence

The “blind” here is not only someone who can’t see with their eyes, but anyone who doesn’t understand a particular matter and relies on someone else’s advice. A salon or clinic client is almost always like that: they can’t judge for themselves whether they need keratin, a peel, filler or an implant. It’s forbidden to advise them something that doesn’t suit them — especially when the advice benefits the one giving it. Selling and earning are not forbidden: what’s forbidden is letting the sale replace the advice. It’s almost impossible to check this from the outside, which is why the verse appeals to conscience: only the adviser knows their real motive.

If you follow itThe trust that “they don’t sell you anything extra here” is the main reason a client sees the same stylist or doctor for years and brings the people close to them.
If you break itAn unnecessary procedure means disappointment, money down the drain and sometimes harm to health. Then the client goes to someone who advised honestly — and tells them why they left.
How this shows up in pay

The main rule: no personal commission on upselling and products for the person who gives the advice. Stylists earn from their own services, doctors get a rate plus a small share.

Pay breakdown: Doctor →

Stories by role

Choose a role. Three stories of how the principle is kept, and three of how it is broken.

Responsible not for revenue at any cost, but for the system: clients come back, strong people stay, and the money is counted honestly.

✓ How it’s kept

A target for returning clients, not for procedures

The owner of three salons removed the line “sell this many care treatments per month” from her stylists’ targets. In its place, the motivation plan now had returning clients and their visit ratings. For the first two months, revenue from treatments dipped slightly. By the end of the quarter, clients were asking about treatments on their own — because they no longer felt they were being pushed on them.

✓ How it’s kept

Reviewing the most expensive plans

Once a month, the medical director of an aesthetic clinic takes a few of the treatment plans with the highest bills and goes through them with the doctors, without patient names. There’s one question: was all of this needed by this person? Once it turned out that almost every plan included the same “to consolidate the result” procedure, which the protocol doesn’t require. It was removed, and “they pushed it on me” conversations at the front desk dropped noticeably.

✓ How it’s kept

The commission goes to the clinic, the choice to the doctor

The owner of a dental clinic made a deal with a dental lab that pays the clinic based on order volume. He immediately wrote down a rule: the commission goes to the clinic, not to any doctor personally, and doctors choose the lab on quality alone. When one dentist asked to work with another, more precise lab, the owner agreed without argument. Patients never see this side of things — but they do see crowns that don’t have to be redone.

✕ How it’s broken

A machine that has to “pay for itself”

The owner of a skincare studio bought an expensive lifting device on credit. At a team meeting he said: “Every client over thirty — we offer it.” Within six months the procedure had been done on people who didn’t need it yet, and those who saw no difference quietly left. The loan was paid off, but rebuilding the client base took longer than paying for the machine.

✕ How it’s broken

A penalty for an honest refusal

A nail tech refused to do extensions on a client’s thin, damaged nails and did a strengthening treatment instead. The owner saw the smaller bill and docked the nail tech’s bonus “for a lost service”. Next time the nail tech didn’t refuse — and two weeks later the client came back with lifting and a complaint. The team drew a conclusion the owner hadn’t intended: honesty gets punished here.

✕ How it’s broken

One serum for everyone

A chain made a deal with a professional skincare brand: the sales bonus is shared among the stylists. Within a month, clients with every skin type were being advised the same serum. One regular client asked directly: “Are you recommending this to me or selling it to me?” She didn’t get a clear answer and never came back.

Role guide: Owner / manager →

Nuances: what it says and what it means today

What it says
Whoever leads astray a person who is blind in a certain matter and gives them unsound advice breaks the rule against putting a stumbling block before the blind.
What it means in a salon or clinic
In beauty and medicine the client is almost always “blind” — even if they’re a lawyer, an engineer or a doctor in another field. They don’t know whether their hair can take lightening, whether their skin is ready for device lifting, whether the tooth can be saved. So every piece of professional advice is a responsibility, not just an offer.
What it says
If a person asks you for advice, it’s forbidden to mislead them: you must point them toward what you yourself consider good and right. Helping another person do wrong falls under the same rule, but the plain meaning of the verse is about advice.
What it means in a salon or clinic
The yardstick isn’t “can this be sold” but “would I recommend this if I got nothing out of it”. The breach is already in the advice itself, even if the procedure went without complications and the client noticed nothing.
What it says
The same rule applies to supporting someone who does wrong: they too are blind, because the desire of their heart keeps them from seeing the right path.
What it means in a salon or clinic
A client driven by strong desire — “more volume”, “even longer lashes”, “more in the lips again, though it’s only been a few weeks” — can also be “blinded by desire”. Fulfilling such a request while knowing the harm isn’t service, it’s a stumbling block before the blind.
What it says
In a loan at interest, the rule against putting a stumbling block before the blind is broken not only by the lender, but also by the borrower, and by every intermediary who brings them together, helps or advises either of them.
What it means in a salon or clinic
Everyone in the chain shares the responsibility: the blogger who recommends a procedure to her followers, the operator who “steers” someone toward a more expensive package on the phone, the partner who pays for referrals. “I was just passing it on” is no defense.
What it says
Lending without witnesses is forbidden, because it’s a stumbling block before the blind — a temptation for the borrower to deny the debt. With a written note it’s even better.
What it means in a salon or clinic
The rule also covers situations that push people toward mistakes. Spoken advice with no record (“the stylist said once would be enough”) is fertile ground for misunderstandings. The recommendation, the number of sessions and the price — in writing: in the client’s file and in their hands.
What it says
Do not take a bribe, for a bribe blinds those who see and twists the words of the just. This was said about judges.
What it means in a salon or clinic
The adviser can become “blind” too. A commission on sales of a particular product, a brand bonus, a lab’s fee for referrals blind even the most honest professional. That’s why the owner is responsible for making sure motivation doesn’t bias the advice.

Grey areas: difficult cases

A client insists on a procedure the professional considers unnecessary: botulinum toxin “for prevention” in their early twenties, volume extensions on weak lashes. Refuse or do it?

The rule is about advice (Preservation of Life 12:14): the professional must honestly say that they don’t recommend it, and why. If the procedure is safe, the client is informed and the decision is truly theirs — the choice is theirs. If there is harm, or signs of being “blinded by desire” (the same 12:14) — refuse. In both cases — a note in the file (Lender and Borrower 2:7).

A partner lab or brand pays the salon or clinic a percentage for referrals and sales. Is that already a breach?

The deal itself — not yet. The breach begins when the commission decides where to send the client and what to advise them: a bribe blinds those who see (Exodus 23:8), and only the adviser knows the real motive. For a salon or clinic this means: choose partners on quality and convenience for the client, don’t tie the commission to an individual professional, and don’t hide it.

A stylist or doctor recommends products from a line the salon sells, or from their own line.

Here the adviser has an interest. It’s acceptable if the interest is stated out loud, the product really suits this person, a more affordable alternative is named and there’s no “only here” pressure.

Is an upselling target for stylists and administrators already a stumbling block before the blind?

No: what’s forbidden is unsound advice, not selling. But a target for a specific procedure, regardless of who needs it, blinds the adviser (Exodus 23:8), and whoever builds such a system is an intermediary who is also responsible (Lender and Borrower 4:2). It’s safer to count returning clients and their visit ratings next to upsells, not instead of them.

“If we refuse, she’ll go elsewhere and get it done worse.” Can we do it ourselves?

The rule is addressed to the one giving advice (Preservation of Life 12:14): someone else’s possible mistake doesn’t make our advice sound. If the procedure harms the person — refuse, and explain the risks so that wherever she goes, she decides knowing them.

How to measure it

Compare each professional’s revenue and upsells with whether clients come back to them and how they rate the visit. A high bill next to low returns and weak ratings is a signal that “they recommend too much”.

Visits and revenue for each stylist and doctoralready counts
New clients returning to the professional from their first visitalready counts
Client visit rating from 1 to 5 by stylist and doctoralready counts
Administrators’ upsells and discounts — separately from each otheralready counts
Return rate of all the professional’s clients, not just newcomerscoming
Complaint log, including “pushed on me” and “just selling”coming
Redos and repeat correctionscoming

Three questions for a team meeting

  1. Which service or product do we recommend most often — and would we recommend it just as often if there were no bonus for it?
  2. Where in our motivation plan or partnerships is there a bribe that blinds — even a very small one?
  3. Which piece of advice from our social media or mailings in the past six months would a stylist or doctor not sign with their own name?

Who else works this way

These are basic universal principles, tested by companies in different countries regardless of faith and culture, and some of them are written into laws and professional standards.

Mayo Clinic For more than 40 years, doctors have been on salary only, with no volume bonuses: so that nothing pushes them to prescribe more than the patient needs. Source: www.advisory.com
Kaiser Permanente Doctors are salaried and practice evidence-based medicine — advice doesn’t depend on how much is sold. Source: about.kaiserpermanente.org

We first test these approaches in practice with the salons we work with. We don’t name them or share their numbers — it is their data, and we protect their confidentiality. That is why we cite open sources: you can open and check each one yourself.

Applying these principles to salons and clinics is our interpretation: these are principles of ethics, not legal or medical advice. The stories are fictional; any resemblance is coincidental. Source: Bible · Maimonides