← Business ethics
✓ Do

Give the right advice

A care or treatment plan in the client’s hands — with options and a price for each.

Whoever comes to you for advice — give them advice that is right for them.

Maimonides, On the Preservation of Life 12:14

The essence

It is not enough simply to avoid giving bad advice — you have to give advice that fits this particular person: their skin, hair, health, budget and time, not something “generally useful” or whatever is most profitable for the salon or clinic. Good advice is honest, clear, comes with options and the price of each, and leaves the right to say “no” without pressure. The rule does not require giving advice for free or giving up on selling: a sale is the result of advice, not its goal.

If you follow itThe person comes back for the next piece of advice — and for the service along with it; clients who had their options explained honestly cancel less often, ask for refunds less often and bring friends more often.
If you break itThe client goes to the internet or a competitor for advice — and then goes there for the service too; “pushed” sales come back as cancelled courses, refunds and reviews saying “they worked me over”.
How this shows up in pay

A doctor’s bonus is for quality and patients coming back, not for the size of the treatment plan; a written plan with options is the standard, not a sale.

Pay breakdown: Doctor →

Stories by role

Choose a role. Three stories of how the principle is kept, and three of how it is broken.

Responsible not for revenue at any cost, but for the system: clients come back, strong people stay, and the money is counted honestly.

✓ How it’s kept

A plan is the standard, not a bonus

The owner of a small salon chain noticed that a week after a cosmetologist’s consultation, clients no longer remembered what they had been advised. She introduced a rule: after every first consultation, a short plan goes out by messenger — what we’ll do, how many times, what each option costs and what can be done at home. At first the staff grumbled that it took extra time. Within a few months the “but I was told something different” arguments had all but disappeared, and people started booking repeat visits on their own.

✓ How it’s kept

A list of “where we honestly refer”

Together with his doctors, the owner of a dental clinic put together a list of trusted colleagues: an orthodontist, an implant surgeon, a pediatric dentist — for cases the clinic doesn’t handle or handles less well. The list is at hand at every front desk. Patients who were referred honestly came back for cleanings and treatment and brought their families. And the colleagues on the list started referring people back.

✓ How it’s kept

A consultation gets its own time

The head of an aesthetic medicine clinic saw that consultations had been squeezed into fifteen minutes between procedures. She restored a proper time slot and removed “same-day procedure sales” from the doctors’ performance metrics. The doctors started explaining options instead of a hurried “let’s do it today”. Fewer people dropped out mid-course: they arrived for the procedure with no doubts left.

✕ How it’s broken

“We don’t let our clients go anywhere”

A salon owner forbade the stylists to recommend other places: “We don’t hand clients to competitors.” A client allergic to regular hair color needed an ammonia-free line the salon didn’t carry, and the stylist silently colored her hair with what they had. Irritation, a complaint on social media — and the client left, taking her friends with her. The competitor got her anyway, only now with a bad story about this salon.

✕ How it’s broken

A consultation measured by the receipt

The head of a cosmetology chain paid a consultation bonus only when the client bought a course the same day. Consultants quickly learned to “push”: discount today only, slots are running out, “later will be too late”. Upfront sales rose, followed by cancelled courses, refunds and reviews saying “they worked me over”. Fewer and fewer people came in just for advice.

✕ How it’s broken

One package for everyone

A studio owner decided to simplify sales: everyone asking about facial care gets the same “renewal package” of several treatments. A young client with sensitive skin came in for basic hydration and got the same package, “because that’s what’s on the price list”. After the third treatment her skin turned red, and the course had to be stopped. A package that was the same for everyone was not advice for her.

Role guide: Owner / manager →

Nuances: what it says and what it means today

What it says
Advice must be right for him — for the person asking, in his circumstances.
What it means in a salon or clinic
A plan built around the person: skin or hair type, contraindications, budget, schedule. You don’t recommend a peel before a beach vacation or a long course to someone moving away in a month, and you honestly name the cheaper option to someone for whom it’s expensive.
What it says
Instead of misleading a person, direct them to what you yourself consider good and right.
What it means in a salon or clinic
A simple test for a stylist or doctor: would I give my own mother or sister the same advice in the same situation? If not, it’s the wrong advice, however profitable the sale. An honest referral is part of the right advice: a rash that won’t go away — to a dermatologist, heavy hair loss — to a trichologist, a device you don’t have — to where it is.
What it says
It is forbidden to speak in a flattering and deceitful way: one thing on the lips, another in the heart. You may not even pretend to insist on giving a gift when you know it won’t be accepted. Speech must be truthful only.
What it means in a salon or clinic
What the specialist wrote on the chart and what they told the client are one and the same. No “gift” whose price is already built into the package, and no compliments to “close” a decision.
What it says
A wise person conducts business honestly and in good faith: his “no” is “no”, his “yes” is “yes”.
What it means in a salon or clinic
“This procedure won’t help you” is complete advice, not a lost sale. A clear “yes” or “no” instead of a vague “well, we could try”.
What it says
Whoever can save another and does not breaks the biblical command “do not stand by the blood of your neighbor”; likewise whoever hears of danger to another and does not warn them.
What it means in a salon or clinic
The right advice is sometimes unrequested. A pedicurist sees signs of nail fungus, a cosmetologist a mole that has changed, a dentist inflamed gums: say so calmly, even if the person came in “for something else”.
What it says
Healing is a doctor’s direct duty: when you see a person in danger and can save them with your body, your money or your knowledge.
What it means in a salon or clinic
Advice is also help through knowledge. A consultation after which the client bought nothing but understood what they need is work done, not time lost.

Grey areas: difficult cases

A client asks: “This procedure is cheaper somewhere else — maybe I should go there?”

Advice must be right for them (Maimonides, On the Preservation of Life 12:14). Explain honestly what your price is made up of and what’s worth comparing: materials, the device, the specialist’s experience, aftercare. If it really is better for them there, say so. Trust comes back with the next request.

Is it fair to charge for a consultation if advice is supposed to be selfless?

There is one requirement: the advice must be right for the person asking (Maimonides, On the Preservation of Life 12:14); payment for a specialist’s time and work is not discussed there. For a salon or clinic this means: a consultation can be paid as the specialist’s time, but the advice must not depend on whether the person buys a procedure.

A client chooses the cheapest option in the plan, which the specialist considers insufficient.

The advice has been given — the decision is the client’s. Say honestly what result to expect from this option: “yes” means “yes”, “no” means “no” (Maimonides, Character Traits 5:13), without scare tactics and without “then nothing will work”. Record the choice and the explanation on the card, so there’s something to build on next time.

An administrator or operator isn’t a specialist. How can they give the right advice?

Don’t take on what you’re not an expert in: questions about health and contraindications go to the doctor or the specialist. But within your own role, tell the truth: which specialist works with exactly this kind of request, what the consultation costs, what to bring. Say what you think, not what you “need to sell” (Maimonides, Character Traits 2:6).

A specialist sees a problem nobody asked about: nail fungus, a changed mole. Should they say something?

Yes. Whoever knows of danger to another and does not warn them is standing by (Maimonides, On the Preservation of Life 1:14). Say it calmly, in private, without a diagnosis and without scaring anyone: “If I were you, I’d show this to a doctor.” The doctor makes the diagnosis; the specialist honestly says what they see.

How to measure it

Right advice shows not in same-day sales but in whether the person comes back after the first visit and books what they were advised. Upsells and discounts are worth looking at separately from the main service — so advice doesn’t turn into a sales target.

New clients returning after the first visitalready counts
Repeat booking in the same service areaalready counts
Recommended date of the next visitalready counts
Client visit ratingalready counts
Upsells and discounts separate from the main servicealready counts
“Plan given” mark after a consultationcoming
Referrals to other specialists and how they turned outcoming

Three questions for a team meeting

  1. Does every new client get a plan with options and prices after a consultation — and how many people got one last week?
  2. When did we last honestly refer a client elsewhere because it was better for them there — and what happened to them next?
  3. What should a person know after a consultation, even if they buy nothing?

Who else works this way

These are basic universal principles, tested by companies in different countries regardless of faith and culture, and some of them are written into laws and professional standards.

Patagonia On Black Friday 2011 — an ad in the New York Times saying “Don’t Buy This Jacket”: a call to buy less, only what is truly needed. Source: www.patagonia.com.au

We first test these approaches in practice with the salons we work with. We don’t name them or share their numbers — it is their data, and we protect their confidentiality. That is why we cite open sources: you can open and check each one yourself.

Applying these principles to salons and clinics is our interpretation: these are principles of ethics, not legal or medical advice. The stories are fictional; any resemblance is coincidental. Source: Bible · Maimonides